Synagogue Behavior

And [in a similar vein], R. Zeira says [that] R. Ḥisda says: The congregation is not permitted to answer amen [to the blessing recited over the Torah reading] until the blessing of the one reading [from the Torah] concludes from his mouth. And the reader is not permitted to [begin] reading from the Torah until [the response] amen [to the preceding blessing] concludes from the mouths of the congregation. And the translator is not permitted to begin the translation [of the Torah reading] until [the reading of] the verse [from the Torah] concludes from the mouth of the reader. And the reader is not permitted to begin [reading] another verse until the translation concludes from the mouth of the translator.

R. Tanḥuma says [that] R. Joshua ben Levi says: The one who concludes with a [reading from] the Prophets [haftarah] must first read [several verses] from the Torah. And R. Tanḥuma says [that] R. Joshua ben Levi says: The one who concludes is not permitted to conclude with [a reading from] the Prophets until the Torah scroll is furled.

And R. Tanḥuma says that R. Joshua ben Levi says: The prayer leader is not permitted to uncover [the decorative covering of] the ark in public, out of respect for the congregation. [It is inappropriate to have the congregation wait while doing this.]

And R. Tanḥuma says [that] R. Joshua ben Levi says: The congregation is not permitted to leave [the synagogue after the Torah reading] until the Torah scroll has been taken and [prepared to be] returned to its place, [as the Torah scroll used to be stored near the synagogue]. And Samuel said: [They may not leave] until [the Torah scroll] is [actually] taken out [of the synagogue, out of respect for the Torah scroll].

And they do not disagree [about the halakhah. Rather, they were discussing different situations]. This [statement of R. Joshua ben Levi is referring to a case] where there is another exit. [When the Torah scroll is being taken out of one exit, people may leave through the other exit. However,] that [statement of Samuel is referring to a case] where there is no other exit [and therefore the congregation must wait until the Torah is carried out]. Rava said: [The sage] bar Ahina explained to me [that this halakhah is derived from the verse]: After the Lord your God you shall walk (Deuteronomy 13:5) [meaning that one must walk after the Torah scroll and not in front of it].

Published in: The Posen Library of Jewish Culture and Civilization, vol. 2: Emerging Judaism.

Engage with this Source

The rabbis establish respectful procedures for the blessing, reading, and translation of the Torah and for exiting the synagogue.

Read more

You may also like