Battle between Hyrcanus II and Aristobulus II

A man should not teach his son Greek. Our rabbis taught: When the Hasmonean kings laid siege to each other, Hyrcanus was outside [of the city of Jerusalem] and Aristobulus was inside [the city]. Every day [those inside the city] would lower a basket of dinars [to those laying siege to the city], and they would take up [animals for] the daily sacrifice, [which was provided by those outside the city in exchange]. There was one elder there [inside the city] who was familiar with Greek wisdom; he spoke in a foreign tongue to those [outside the city] using Greek wisdom and said to them: As long as [those inside the city] are continuing their Temple service, they will not be given over into your hands. The next day, [those inside the city] lowered down their basket full of dinars and [began] taking up a pig [given by those outside the city, in order to prevent the daily Temple service]. When the pig was raised halfway up the wall, it stuck out its nails [into the wall], and the land of Israel shook [across] four hundred parasangs. At that time they said: Cursed is the man who raises pigs and cursed is the man who teaches his son Greek wisdom.

Translated by Matthew Goldstone.

Published in: The Posen Library of Jewish Culture and Civilization, vol. 2: Emerging Judaism.

Engage with this Source

In the aftermath of the death of Queen Salome Alexandra (Shelamzion) in 67 BCE, her sons Hyrcanus II and Aristobulus II struggled for power, resulting in a civil war (see “Hyrcanus II and Aristobulus II”). The Babylonian Talmud relates that Hyrcanus’ forces won the war by disrupting the Temple service, which the Talmud blames on someone proficient in Greek language and philosophy. The anecdote is used to support a condemnation of Greek culture.

Read more

You may also like