Bavli Ḥagigah

The words of the wise are as goads, and as nails well fastened are those that are composed in collections; they are given from one shepherd (Ecclesiastes 12:11).

Why are matters of Torah compared to a goad? To tell you [that] just as this goad directs the cow to her furrow to bring forth [sustenance for] life to the world, so too the words of Torah direct those who study them from the paths of death to the paths of life. If so, [should you think that—Ed.] just as this goad is movable, so too matters of Torah are movable, the verse states: Nails. If so, [should you think that—Ed.] just as this nail is diminished [in size] and does not expand, so too matters of Torah are diminished and do not expand, the verse states: Well fastened [netu‘im]. Just as this plant [neti‘a] flourishes and multiplies, so too matters of Torah flourish and multiply.

Those that are composed in collections [ba‘alei ’asufot]: These are Torah scholars who sit in many groups [’asupot] and engage in Torah [study. Some of] these [sages] render [an object or person] ritually impure and these render it pure; these prohibit [an action] and these permit [it]; these deem [an item] invalid and these deem it valid.

Lest a person say: Now, how can I study Torah [when it contains so many different opinions]? The verse states: They are all given from one shepherd (Ecclesiastes 12:11). One God gave them; one leader, [i.e., Moses,] said them from the mouth of the Master of all creation, as it is written: And God spoke all these words (Exodus 20:1).

So too, you make your ears like a funnel and acquire for yourself an understanding heart to hear the statements of [those] who render [objects] ritually impure and the statements of [those] who render [them] pure; the statements of [those] who prohibit [actions] and the statements of [those] who permit [them]; the statements of [those] who deem [items] invalid and the statements of [those] who deem [them] valid.

Published in: The Posen Library of Jewish Culture and Civilization, vol. 2: Emerging Judaism.

Engage with this Source

The valorization of dialectic, as well as the celebration of the Torah’s multivocality seen in the Jerusalem Talmud (e.g., y. Sanhedrin 4:1–2, 22a), continues in the Babylonian Talmud. By means of an artful midrashic reading of a verse from Ecclesiastes, b. Ḥagigah 3b at once articulates the anxiety engendered by the presence of contradictory views and resolves it by asserting that all views are grounded in the divine revelation conveyed to Moses.

Read more

You may also like