Jacob and Esau Battle

Chapter 37

1On the day that Isaac, the father of Jacob and Esau, died, Esau’s sons heard that Isaac had given the birthright to his younger son Jacob. They became very angry. 2They quarreled with their father: “Why is it that when you are the older and Jacob the younger, your father gave Jacob the birthright and deposed you?” 3He said to them, “Because I gave the right of the firstborn to Jacob in exchange for a little lentil broth. The day my father sent me to hunt game so that he could eat [it] and bless me, he came in a crafty way and brought in food and drink to my father. My father blessed him and put me under his control. 4Now our father has made us—me and him—swear that we will not seek harm, the one against his brother, and that we will continue in [a state of] mutual love and peace, each with his brother, so that we should not corrupt our behavior.” 5They said to him, “We will not listen to you by making peace with him because our strength is greater than his strength, and we are stronger than he is. We will go against him, kill him, and destroy his sons. If you do not go with us, we will harm you, too. 6Now listen to us: let us send to Aram, Philistia, Moab, and Ammon; and let us choose for ourselves select men who are brave in battle. Then let us go against him, make war with him, and uproot him from the earth before he gains strength.” 7Their father said to them, “Do not go and do not make war with him so that you may not fall before him.” 8They said to him, “Is this not the very way you have acted from your youth until today? You are putting your neck beneath his yoke. We will not listen to what you are saying.”

9So they sent to Aram and to their father’s friend Aduram. Together with them they hired for themselves 1,000 fighting men, select warriors. 10There came to them from Moab and from the Ammonites 1,000 select men who were hired; from the Philistines 1,000 select warriors; from Edom and the Horites 1,000 select fighters, and from the Kittim strong warriors. 11They said to their father, “Go out; lead them. Otherwise we will kill you.” 12He was filled with anger and wrath when he saw that his sons were forcing him to go in front in order to lead them to his brother Jacob. 13But he remembered all the bad things that were hidden in his mind against his brother Jacob, and he did not remember the oath that he had sworn to his father and mother not to seek harm against Jacob throughout his entire lifetime.

14During all this time, Jacob was unaware that they were coming to him for battle. He, for his part, was mourning for his wife until they approached him near the tower with 4,000 warriors. 15The people of Hebron sent word to him: “Your brother has just now come against you to fight you with 4,000 men who have swords buckled on and are carrying shields and weapons.” They told him because they loved Jacob more than Esau, since Jacob was a more generous and kind man than Esau. 16But Jacob did not believe [it] until they came near the tower. 17Then he closed the gates of the tower, stood on the top, and spoke with his brother Esau. He said, “It is a fine consolation that you have come to give me for my wife who has died. Is this the oath that you swore to your father and your mother twice before he died? You have violated the oath and were condemned in the hour when you swore [it] to your father.” 18Then Esau said in reply to him, “Neither humankind nor serpents have a true oath that they, once they have sworn, have sworn [it as valid] forever. Every day they desire harm for one another, how to kill his enemy and opponent. 19You hate me and my sons forever. There is no observing of brotherly ties with you. 20Listen to what I have to say to you. If a pig changes its hide and makes its hair limp like wool; and horns like the horns of a ram and sheep go out on its head, then I will observe brotherly ties with you. The breasts have been separated from their mother, for you have not been a brother to me. 21If wolves make peace with lambs so that they do not eat them or injure them; and if they have resolved to treat them well, then there will be peace in my mind for you. 22If a lion becomes the friend of a bull and a confidant, and if it is harnessed together with it in a yoke and plows [as] one yoke, then I will make peace with you. 23If the ravens turn white like a pelican, then know that I love you and will make peace with you. [As for] you—be uprooted and your children are being uprooted. There is to be no peace for you.” 24When Jacob saw that he was adversely inclined toward him from his mind and his entire self so that he could kill him and [that] he was coming and bounding along like a boar that comes upon the spear that pierces it and kills it but does not pull back from it, 25then he told his sons and his servants to attack him and all his companions.

Chapter 38

1After this Judah spoke to his father Jacob and said to him, “Draw your bow, father; shoot your arrow; strike the enemy; and kill the foe. May you have the strength because we will not kill your brother, since he is your brother and he is similar to you, and, in our estimation, he is like you in honor.” 2Jacob then stretched his bow, shot an arrow, struck his brother Esau on his right breast, and killed him. 3He shot a second arrow and hit Aduran the Aramean on his left breast; he drove him back and killed him. 4After this Jacob’s sons—they and their servants—went out, dividing themselves to the four sides of the tower. 5Judah went out first. Naphtali and Gad were with him, and 50 servants were with them on the south side of the tower. They killed everyone whom they found in front of them. No one at all escaped from them. 6Levi, Dan, and Asher went out on the east side of the tower, and 50 were with them. They killed the Moabite and Ammonite bands. 7Reuben, Issachar, and Zebulun went out on the north side of the tower, and their 50 with them. They too killed the Philistine fighting men. 8Simeon, Benjamin, and Enoch—Reuben’s son—went out on the west side of the tower, and their 50 with them. Of [the people of] Edom and the Horites they killed 400 strong warriors, and 600 ran away. Esau’s four sons ran away with them. They left their slain father thrown on the hill that is in Adoraim. 9Jacob’s sons pursued them as far as Mount Seir, while Jacob buried his brother on the hill that is in Adoraim and then returned to the tower. 10Jacob’s sons besieged Esau’s sons in Mount Seir. They bowed their neck to become servants for Jacob’s sons. 11They sent to their father [to ask] whether they should make peace with them or kill them. 12Jacob sent word to his sons to make peace. So they made peace with them and placed the yoke of servitude on them so that they should pay tribute to Jacob and his sons for all time. 13They continued paying tribute to Jacob until the day that he went down to Egypt. 14The Edomites have not extricated themselves from the yoke of servitude that Jacob’s sons imposed on them until today.

Translated by James C. VanderKam.

Notes

Words in brackets appear in the original translation.

Credits

Jubilees 37:1–38:14, trans. James C. VanderKam, in James C. VanderKam, Jubilees: A Commentary in Two Volumes, vol. 1, ed. Sidnie White Crawford, Hermeneia: A Critical and Historical Commentary on the Bible (Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2018), pp. 971–72, 989. Used with permission of 1517 Media.

Published in: The Posen Library of Jewish Culture and Civilization, vol. 2: Emerging Judaism.

Engage with this Source

The book of Jubilees retells the biblical story of the twin brothers Jacob and Esau with some surprising twists. In this text, although Rebekah and Isaac have made Esau swear not to harm Jacob, Esau’s sons force him to fight his brother. In contrast to the biblical narrative, in which Jacob and Esau are reconciled (see Genesis 33:1–16), Jubilees has Jacob kill Esau, likewise with his sons’ encouragement. Jacob’s sons then subject Esau’s sons to servitude, fulfilling the words God spoke to Rebekah when she was pregnant: “Two nations are in your womb, two separate peoples shall issue from your body. One people shall be mightier than the other, and the older shall serve the younger” (Genesis 25:23, NJPS). 

For other ancient approaches to the story of Jacob and Esau, see Esau as Rome and Jacob and Esau as Christians and Jews.

Read more

You may also like