Alternative Temples in Antiquity

1st Century BCE–6th Century CE
Restricted
Some content is unavailable to non-members, please log in or sign up for free for full access.

The Temple of Jerusalem was never the only place of worship and sacrifice. In the biblical period, local shrines existed before, and even after, the effort to centralize the ritual cult in the Jerusalem Temple. The Jewish mercenary colony at Elephantine, Egypt, had its own temple from perhaps as early as the seventh century to at least the early fourth century BCE. At Mount Gerizim, the Samaritans—in many ways indistinguishable from Judeans—had their own temple until it was destroyed in the Hasmonean period. And in the Hellenistic period and later, sources refer to a temple established by Onias, a displaced high priest, at Leontopolis in Egypt. However, most sources from the Hellenistic and Roman periods indicate that the Jerusalem Temple was the cultic center of the Jewish people until its destruction in 70 CE.

Related Primary Sources

Primary Source

Onias Receives Permission to Build a Temple

Jewish Antiquities 13.62–73
Public Access
Text
But then the son of Onias the high priest, who bore the same name as his father, having fled to King Ptolemy—the one who was called Philometor—was residing in Alexandria, as I mentioned earlier. When…

Primary Source

The Construction of Onias’ Temple

The Jewish War 7.426–432
Restricted
Text
Ptolemy was persuaded by this proposal, and granted Onias a site twenty miles from Memphis in the borough of Heliopolis. Here Onias built a fort, and then constructed his temple out of huge stones…

Primary Source

The Talmud on the Temple of Onias

b. Menaḥot 109a–b
Public Access
Text
[ONE WHO SAYS:] IT [IS INCUMBENT] UPON ME [TO BRING] A BURNT OFFERING, MUST SACRIFICE IT IN THE TEMPLE [IN JERUSALEM]. AND IF HE SACRIFICED IT IN THE TEMPLE OF ONIAS, HE HAS NOT FULFILLED [HIS…

Primary Source

The Samaritan Temple at Mount Gerizim

Jewish Antiquities 13.74–79

Public Access
Text
Now it happened that the Jews in Alexandria and the Samaritans who worshiped at the temple on Mount Gerizim, which was built in the days of Alexander, were in conflict. They were disputing about their…

Primary Source

Samaritan Sacred Precinct atop Mount Gerizim

Restricted
Image
The Samaritans, who trace their ancestry to the northern tribes of Israel, lived alongside the Jewish community of Judea in the Second Temple period. The Samaritans’ holy book, known as the Samaritan…