Jewish Demography and Culture on the Eve of WWI
Amid an ongoing period of immigration and economic upheaval, the Jews of the world were subject to the immigration policies of their local governments.
Immigration and Assimilation
Two Jewish intellectuals and public activists combined up-to-date information with a kind of political prophecy, as they sketched a broad overview of the demographic-cultural situation at the beginning of the second decade of the twentieth century. Let us entertain their perspective, as presented in 1911.
The Zionist sociologist and economist Arthur Ruppin (1876–1943) devised a socioeconomic cultural model that largely reflected the international condition of the Jewish community on the eve of the Great War, without any reference to settlement in Israel. He introduced this model in 1904 in his book Die Juden der Gegenwart (The Jews of Today), although he updated it in an edition published in 1911 (and several more times in the following years) based on changes in the given statistics. The bottom line of this study was that immigration and urbanization—first and foremost in lands which had political freedom, such as England and the countries of North America—were deterministically leading to the elimination of the Jewish entity. The second observer, the British historian Lucien Wolf (1857–1930), one of the greatest critics of Zionism, was forced to admit in 1911, in an entry he wrote for the Encyclopedia Britannica, that the Zionist movement had reached a position of great influence in the Jewish world.
The Status of the Jews: An Ongoing Process of Socioeconomic Transition
According to Ruppin, the status of the Jews on the eve of the war reflected the results of an ongoing process of socioeconomic transition, which also determined their cultural status. Ruppin exposed the close relationship between immigration and urbanization, and he witnessed its most extreme example—the complete assimilation that developed among Berlin Jews. After analyzing the positions of hundreds of thousands of Jews in the slums of London and New York, he concluded that immigration and urbanization were also raising up the Jewish masses from poverty to affluence in a relatively short time and providing many thousands of Eastern Europeans with secure livelihoods.
These observations were also correct to one degree or another—albeit on different scales from place to place—with regard to the rest of the Jewish diaspora, in its various communities. In the Middle East, for example, immigrant communities were built up in urban centers that grew rapidly in the late nineteenth century, as ancient commercial centers lost their economic importance and were replaced by modern commercial port cities in the eastern Mediterranean Basin. Thus, Beirut in Lebanon, like Odessa on the coast of the Black Sea, served as a magnet for various ethnic-religious groups. In the city, the new arrivals were exposed to Western influences in the educational institutions of the colonial powers and also to a modern Arab culture, as Beirut was one of its leading focal points. One can identify a similar development even in the emigration of thousands of Yemeni Jews to Palestine, which reached its apex right before the outbreak of the Great War, with some of them settling in the regenerating coastal cities.
The Case of Budapest on the Eve of World War I
Budapest, at the time still an imperial capital, had a population of roughly 200,000 Jews on the eve of the war. This city attracted tens of thousands of Jewish settlers from all over the Austro-Hungarian Empire. Between 1880 and 1910 the number of Jews in the city increased almost threefold! While the Jewish commercial elite enthusiastically accepted the new immigration policies, underwent a process of profound Magyarization, identified with Hungarian nationalism, and took a significant part in the cultural scene, the city was also home to thousands of immigrants from peripheral communities who devoutly maintained a traditional Jewish life. Accordingly, it was difficult to find significant support for the Zionist version of nationalism in prewar Budapest. One way or another, the state of affairs in the capital of the Hungarian section of the dual monarchy shows that the extent of modern Jewish national awakening in highly populated areas of urban immigrants was largely determined by the government’s integration policy. It would seem that the Budapest case, on the eve of World War I, matched the rosy picture that Lucien Wolf had hoped to see before him: “under the influence of religious toleration and the naturalization laws, nationalities are daily losing more of their racial character.”123
Jewish life, after three decades of massive immigration, dramatic exposure to the promising, and at the same time threatening, challenges of the capitalist economy, and the reorganization of society in an urban reality, or into innovative and unprecedented forms that were designed to shape a “new Jew,” did indeed incorporate a dialectical combination of centrifugal and centripetal forces. However, these were far more complex than Ruppin and Wolf suggested in their quasi-prophetic statements of 1911. Crime and prostitution flourished in Warsaw, Odessa, Constantinople, New York, and Buenos Aires. By contrast, the rapid social mobility of immigrants in the urban environment and their swift integration into the liberal professions, the written media, literature, and art, as well as architecture, were perceived by non-Jews in the urban environment as a taking over, and/or “Judaizing” of the surrounding society.