Ottoman Jewish Opposition to Zionism
1909
Nearly fifteen years ago, following frequent persecutions against our coreligionists in Russia and Romania, a few European Jews conceived of the project of establishing a Jewish state in Palestine and transporting our unfortunate brothers persecuted in other countries [to that land]. Honest people of good faith who believe in the possibility of…
The Young Turk Revolution of 1908 brought a new era of parliamentary rule to the Ottoman Empire, inspiring hopes for equality among its minorities. Among the hopeful voices was that of David Fresco, a leading Jewish journalist in Constantinople and strong advocate of Ottomanism. Fresco promoted a shared Ottoman citizenship that transcended ethnic and religious lines and urged Jews to assimilate culturally and linguistically. In 1909, Fresco published articles in the Ladino press (later translated into French) denouncing Zionism and Jewish settlement in Palestine as threats to Ottoman unity. His position sparked fierce backlash, revealing deepening divisions within Ottoman Jewry.
What arguments did Fresco advance against Zionism? What political, social, or personal factors might have shaped his position?
Fresco repeatedly warned his readers that Zionism would “distract” them from their “duty.” What do you think he meant by this, and what responsibilities was he emphasizing for Ottoman Jews?
Imagine you are an Ottoman Jewish journalist in 1909 making the case for or against Zionism. Using what you know of the historical context, write a short essay presenting your argument.
Related Guide
Politics, Culture, and Religion at the Turn of the Twentieth Century
Jewish politics became more ideological, driving cultural change and defining nationalism. Tensions arose between secular movements and religious traditionalism.
You may also like
Mission of Ha-Ḥerut
The Platform of Hashomer
Letter to Henrietta Szold
Bar-Kokhba