To the Modern Girl: A Rebuke of Modernity
1898
It is you, modern girls, whom I address. The modern spirit has completely changed your natures. If the sages of old, who spoke so much about the wonderful strength of woman as opposed to man, found themselves in this epoch and saw your spinelessness, the way you let yourselves be seduced by men and fall into their traps, they would say: Is this…
Reina ha-Kohen’s fiery essay “To the Modern Girl,” published in nineteenth-century Salonika, warns Jewish women that the “modern spirit” has upended the traditional gender and moral order. Addressing “modern girls,” she laments that women once possessed immense moral and emotional power but have become weak and vain, seduced by fashion, wealth, and men’s deceit. Ha-Kohen argues that in earlier times, women’s strength inspired passion and reverence, but modernity has reversed this balance—men now dominate through the very arts of manipulation once associated with women. She calls on Jewish women to reject materialism and superficial beauty, reclaim virtue and piety, and resist the corrupting influence of Western modernity that, in her view, has undermined both faith and femininity.
How would you characterize ha-Kohen’s views on the biblical and other ancient women she describes? Is she advocating their methods?
What is ha-Kohen’s motivation for this article? What changes in the world, or the “modern spirit” as she calls it, led ha-Kohen to address Jewish women at that time?
Do you think ha-Kohen addresses young women effectively? Are there other methods she could have used to reach her target audience?
Related Guide
Politics, Culture, and Religion at the Turn of the Twentieth Century
Jewish politics became more ideological, driving cultural change and defining nationalism. Tensions arose between secular movements and religious traditionalism.