Letter to Judah Barzillai of Barcelona
Abraham bar Ḥiyya
ca. 1120
Abraham bar Ḥiyya wrote this letter to Judah Barzillai following a heated debate about the propriety of postponing a wedding of one of bar Ḥiyya’s students due to the inauspicious positions of the stars. The debate between bar Ḥiyya and Judah took place at the wedding itself, and after bar Ḥiyya proposed the delay, Judah retorted that such ideas verged on idolatry and were prohibited as “the ways of the Chaldeans.” Bar Ḥiyya wrote this defense of his position, outlining why he thought the study of astrology was obligatory and how one should react to ominous predictions on the part of the stars. In response to Judah’s charge, bar Ḥiyya argued that the Talmud (b. Pesaḥim 113b) prohibits “asking” the Chaldeans, not adhering to their knowledge. This excerpt outlines the basic contours of astronomy and astrology and then argues that the rabbis themselves endorsed the study and practice of astronomy and astrology.
Related Guide
Intellectual Culture in the Early Medieval World
Creator Bio
Abraham bar Ḥiyya
Abraham bar Ḥiyya was a philosopher, mathematician, and scientist who lived in Barcelona. He apparently held a position of leadership recognized by both Jewish and non-Jewish communities, but the details are not precisely known. His The Foundations of Understanding and the Tower of Faith (Yesode ha-tevunah u-migdal ha-emunah) was the first Hebrew encyclopedia of science; only the introduction and part of the first treatise are extant. In that and other works, he attempted to render Arabic and Greek scientific terms in Hebrew, thus shaping the evolution of the Hebrew language in the medieval period. Bar Ḥiyya was interested in astrology and once sought to postpone a wedding because the stars were not properly aligned, a position that led to a clash with Judah Barzillai, also of Barcelona. Bar Ḥiyya’s penchant for astrology also manifested itself in detailed eschatological speculations in The Scroll of the Revealer (Megilat ha-megaleh); he deduced that the redemption would arrive in 1383 and that the resurrection of the dead would take place in 1448.
You may also like
A Manuscript Page from The Book of Musta‘īnī
Treatise on the Jewish Calendar
Scroll of the Revealer
Megilat ha-megaleh, Introduction, Chapters 2, 5 (selections)