[The Book of] Forbidden and Permitted

Chapter 48

Laws of ‘Orlah

And when you shall come into the land, [and shall have planted all manner of trees for food,] then you shall count its fruit as forbidden (Leviticus 19:23). The prohibition of ‘orlah in this day is not from the Bible but is a tradition, [transmitted] from community to community, from Moses our teacher. It is [found in] a statement of the Mishnah: “New [produce] is prohibited by the Torah in all places. And ‘orlah is a law. And kila’yim [mixtures] are an enactment of the scribes” [m. ‘Orlah 3:9].

The law of ‘orlah prohibits benefiting from its [a new tree’s] fruit and what is secondary to its fruit for three years, according to God’s command: [you shall count] its fruit [as forbidden] (Leviticus 19:23). They explain [its fruit] as including what is secondary to the fruit. [What is that? That which is protection for the fruit; b. Berakhot 36b.] The explanation of “what is secondary” is anything where if it is removed, the fruit is spoiled—it is forbidden—as in the peel [or shell] of a pomegranate, a walnut, or an almond. However, any thing which, if it is removed, the fruit remains [unharmed], is permitted, as in, the leaves and branches.

All fruit is subject to the law of ‘orlah for three years, but after three years, the law of ‘orlah is over, and it [the tree] is subject to the law of the “fourth,” namely, the fourth year. This is called “jubilation,” as it says: And in the fourth year, all its fruit shall be holy, for giving praise to the Lord (Leviticus 19:24).

Afterward, in the fourth year, he shall redeem it and in the fifth year he may eat it [see Leviticus 19:25].

Now if the Temple were standing, he would redeem it in the third or fourth [year] and eat what he redeemed in Jerusalem.

Today, we redeem it [the fruit of the fourth year] even if it is worth a hundredweight in dirhems, and we throw these dirhems away, where nobody can reach them, as it states: “Throw the benefit into the Dead Sea” [see, for example, m. Avodah Zarah 3:9]. They say: Consecrated property worth one hundred dinars [maneh] that one deconsecrated [or redeemed] on a [coin] worth a perutah is [considered] deconsecrated [b. Temurah 27b].

And the one who redeems shall make a blessing, [saying,] “Blessed are You, ruler of the universe, who commanded us [regarding] the redemption of the produce of the fourth [year],” and [“Blessed are You, ruler of the universe,] who has sustained us [sheheḥiyanu].”

I saw in a responsum of R. ‘Amram [regarding] redemption of the [fruit of the] vineyard:

The owner of the vineyard should bring the matter [before] three people, and he should bring fruit from it [i.e., his vineyard], and he should bring a se’ah of barley and bless, [saying, “Blessed are You, ruler of the universe, who commanded us regarding] the redemption of the produce of the fourth [year],” and say, “Transfer the sanctification of this onto these, the barley.” Thereafter he burns them [the barley] in the graveyard, and it is permitted to use the grapes.

I heard of one sage who required squeezing a cluster [of grapes] and then reciting the blessing over it, [saying,] “[Blessed are You, ruler of the universe, . . . regarding] the vine,” and “[Blessed are You, ruler of the universe, who commanded us regarding] the redemption [of the produce of the fourth year]” and [“Blessed are You, ruler of the universe,] who has sustained us [sheheḥiyanu], etc.” and then said, “Transfer, etc. . . . ”

Translated by Daniel Isaac.

Published in: The Posen Library of Jewish Culture and Civilization, vol. 3: Encountering Christianity and Islam.

Engage with this Source

Little is known about the origins of the Judeo-Arabic halakhic work called the [Book of] Forbidden and Permitted (Isur ve-heter), which had fairly wide circulation in the medieval Mediterranean. It appears to have been composed in Arabic-speaking Spain, and it covers a wide range of practical topics. Some chapters are summaries of applicable law and others are commentaries on sections of the Mishnah. This excerpt considers the biblical prohibition against consuming fruit that has grown on a tree during its first three fruit-bearing years (see Leviticus 19:23), which is called ‘orlah. The author records various versions of a rite used (in the absence of the Temple in Jerusalem) to redeem the fruit of the fourth year.

Read more

You may also like